The AIG Selloff is Overdone. It Looks Like a Buy and Hold
Last week, AIG became the lastest example of the skittishness and fear that defines why the market is so volatile. First there was a disclosure in an SEC filing that outside accountants found “material weakness” in AIG’s accounting systems. And then, to cover potential losses in collateralized debt obligations (CDOs), there was also bigger “mark to market” writedowns in Q3 2007, and will be bigger writedowns for Q4, and for Q1 of this year. Analysts moved quickly to revise 2008 earnings lower, and the stock took a 12% haircut off of what is already a pretty depressed price.
The situation reminds me of a trade I had in Capital One stock in July, 2002. It was within a year of 9/11. The market was finally showing signs of life, but still was very skittish. The slightest bit of bad news was met with a ’sell first, ask questions later’ mentality. Kind of like now.
That July, the stock was already down considerably from recent highs in the mid 60s when the company announced a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) that reclassified a healthy portion of their credit card accounts as subprime, and required that they hold a much larger loss reserve. No money went out the door. No actual damage was done. It just reclassified the risk. Yet the stock sold off from around $50 into the high $20s literally in hours.
Yes, it was not the best news, but it was not the end of the world either. Once you took a breath and thought about it, it was easy to realize that suddenly the Capital One card portfolio was in even better shape and far less risky than it was before the announcement. The odds of a downside surprise were significantly reduced. I took the opportunity to double down, and the shares rewarded me by more than doubling in the next two years.
AIG’s current situation reminds me a lot of this. Yes, again, not the best news, but these write downs are for potential losses, and there is a good chance that the vast majority of the write downs AIG is incurring will reverse back into earnings. AIG will only pay out in the event of an actual default, and AIG collects income in the form of premiums for insuring these CDOs.
The stock is at its lowest levels in years. I would await the rest of the write downs to get a full view of what the potential risk is. After that… I won’t say it will double like Capital One did, but the shares are worth considering.
Disclosure: As of publication I have no positions in the stocks mentioned here. I am not a professional, but I am trying this at home. It is highly recommended that you consult a licensed financial advisor or broker before making any and all investment decisions.