After the single wildest week in the markets that I have ever seen… With the goverment bailouts to the rescue… With the SEC ban on shorting stocks… What happens now?
A couple of predictions:
AIG Gets A Private Bailout, Markets Don’t Know What To Think
Hank Greenberg and company will figure out a way to intervene and get there before the $85B federal bailout does. This will bode well for markets… maybe. While generally seen as positive news, it will also be seen as “there goes money that could have bailed out or bought someone else.” Ridiculous thinking in my opinion, but that’s the way it goes.
Markets Will Stabilize Mostly Because Of One Thing
Because the Feds said they would assure the cash value of money market assets to their dollar-for-dollar value. This is important because without it, there is a great chance for a run on banks. A run produces substantial deposit withdraws. Deposit withdraws must be covered by selling assets (admittedly mostly short term assets, but this selling would have a directly negative impact on stocks) which drives markets lower. This stabilization was the most critical piece.
The Short Selling Ban Is A Huge Mistake
An outright ban was just too much. Temporarily reinstate the uptick rule (but only temporarily) and police the naked short selling until it’s stopped. Stopping the naked shorts will stop the dramatic swings we saw in stocks like Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs and Zions.
Remember that shorts perform an important service in the market. First and foremost, they give all investors a way to make money regardless of the market’s direction. I would say that over my lifetime as an investor that 40% of my profits have come from short selling. My single most successful trade was a short sell (In very late 2004, shorting TZOO at $115 and covering in the $20s less than six months later). It takes a fusion of many elements to get a stock to go up, and the failure of only one element to make a stock go down.
Second, it was the shorts who have been saying for more than two years that this was coming. Jim Rodgers, the famous commodities trader, said two years ago that Fannie and Freddie were toast. At the time, Fannie was trading at more than $60 and people thought he was nuts. In May of 2006, Barron’s wrote a cover story on this mess. At the time, they pointed to more than $3 trillion in ARMs that were due to reset at drastically higher interest rates, and the chaos that would ensue.
The shorts warned us, not with rumor mongering or manipulation or sensationalism, but with cold hard data. Now because they profited we blame them. Stupid.
What Happens Now?
At the macro level, look for more of the same wildness in the coming weeks. After election day, look for a rally if McCain wins and no rally if Obama wins. Christmas will just plain suck for retailers, so those stocks are dead money or worse, unless you are WalMart or Costco. Over the next two weeks, the hedge fund dollars that were poured into shorts will now focus on commodities, so look for a big jump in oil in the immediate term. Same with coal and nat gas, but not to the same level as oil. Look for gold to run up like freakin’ crazy.
Two more things: First, the write downs are at about $400 billion. But there is likely more than $600 billion of additional illiquid assets that cannot be sold, so they will likely be written down… unless the government soaks them up, which is a possibility. So unless the government soaks up this slop, the worst is not nearly over. So don’t go loading up on bank stocks. Buy only the big drastic dips and sell into the inevitable surge that follows. Trade them, do not own them, until the picture is much more certain.
Second, pray… I mean literally pray… that people who own homes and have the ability to pay don’t resolve their negative equity problem by throwing the keys back to the bank and walking away. If people who have the ability to pay choose not to, it will be a disaster.
So how am I playing this?
Early Friday morning I sold alot of stuff into the strength (some shares of LVLT, BX and some GS that I picked up in the low $120s on Wed… what a ride that was), and I will continue to be situational. I will be looking hard at BTU, OIL, GLD.
Two pieces of final, somewhat unrelated commentary
First, my last post on Wachovia got pounded, particularly the advice that you should buy if it dipped under $10. The post appeared on seekingalpha.com, for who I am an occasional contributor. You should see the lambasting I took. Some funny stuff.
Then, about three weeks after I made this suggestion, Jim Cramer said the same thing… that you couldn’t ignore Wachovia under $10.
Well guess what? If you bought it when it closed under $10 on Tuesday, you could have unloaded it for more than $18 before the week was over. Last I checked, that’s nearly a double in just a few days, and my most successful prediction to date. So to my detractors I simply ask: Who was right?
Second, I have been an account holder at TD Ameritrade for 12 years… first as Datek, then Ameritrade, then TD Ameritrade. When their systems failed on Friday, for the third time in a year I found myself unable to log into my account when I most needed it. The last time this happened was in January, and on that occasion, I talked to friends of mine who had Etrade accounts that were working just fine. Same with Friday… Etrade was fine while TD was failing. So yesterday, when I finally got in, I began unwinding what was my longest standing financial relationship by transferring out of my account all of my cash. The shares I am holding will come a little later.
When I spoke to the rep at TD this afternoon, I told him that for this to happen three times in a year, someone ought to be calling for not just the CIO’s head, but for the CEO’s head as well. This is their business. This is what they do. How can they allow a single failure, let alone three in a year?
I don’t know, but I can tell you that the next time they go down, I won’t be worried because my money will be somewhere else.
Disclosure: As of publication I am have no positions in the stocks mentioned here, but positions can change at any time. I am not a professional, but I am trying this at home. It is highly recommended that you consult a licensed financial advisor or broker before making any and all investment decisions.
Tags: Business And Life // Add Comment »